Skip to main content

Grade 11 Literature- The Woman Speaks to the Man who has Employed Her Son- Lorna Goodison


Objectives: March 17, 2020
We break from the theme of nature to talk about social issues of men being marginalized




1.After listening to this dramatic presentation .
watch this tutorial of the analysis.



2. Read notes for study 
SUMMARY
The persona in this poem is telling the story of a mother who loved her son. The mother became aware of the child’s presence when she experienced morning sickness. She placed all her hopes in the child and raised him as a single parent because his father was indifferent to the child’s existence. The mother had set no barriers on what the child could become, but is told that he has an employer who values him so much that he is given his own submarine gun. The son tells his mother that his employer is like a father  to him, but the mother wonders at the father figure who purposefully endangers his child. She prepares for her son’s death by going downtown to buy funeral apparel. The mother feels powerless, so she prays for her child and says protective psalms for him. On the other hand, she reads psalms of retribution for the employer and weeps for her son. Her situation does not look good and is likened to a partner system in which she draws both the first and the last hand.
LITERARY DEVICES
1.    SIMILE
Lines 1-2: The persona emphasizes that the mother placed all her hopes in her son. When you are poor, generally, you have no prospects, you only dream and hope. Therefore, the persona uses this metaphor to emphasize the mother’s dependence on her son’s success.
Line 17: The employer is being compared to a father figure. This implies that this person fills a gap in the son’s life.
2.    SARCASM
The persona appears to praise the child’s father by referring to him as ‘fair-minded’. She is, however, chastising him for not only ignoring his son, but all of his other children.
3.    IRONY (situational)
The son innocently tells his mother that his employer values him so much that he gave him a whole submachine gun for himself. The irony in this situation is that if you really care about someone, you do NOT give them a gun due to the negative results that are bound to occur.
4.    ALLUSION (biblical)
Lines 28-29: This line alludes to a particular verse in the Christian Bible, Luke 11 vs 11. The verse questions what the actions of a good father should be.
Lines 38-39: Psalms is a particular chapter in the Christian Bible. In this chapter there are verses for protection, the mother uses those for her son, as well as verses for retribution and rebuking. It is implied that the mother chooses those for the employer.
Lines 43-45: In the Christian Bible, Judas Iscariot betrayed Jesus. Therefore, it does not bode well for the mother if she is in a ‘partnership’ with this person’s mother because she might also be betrayed. The banker in the ‘partnership’ also happens to be the thief on the left hand side of the cross’ mother. This also does not bode well for the mother if the apple doesnot fall far from the tree.
Line 49: Absalom is the son of David, in the Christian Bible. Absalom betrayed his father, which implies that the mother feels betrayed by her son because she has placed all her hopes in him.
IMPORTANT WORDS/ PHRASES
5.    ‘a need to cry for little reasons and a metallic tide rising in her mouth each morning.’
These two symptoms are early signs of pregnancy. The metallic tide refers to vomiting. These signs usually occur in the first trimester of pregnancy.
6.    ‘full term’
This means that the mother carried her son for the full nine months that a pregnancy should last.
7.    ‘tight up under her heart’
This hints at the love that the mother harbours for her child. He was not simply ‘close to her heart’, but ‘tight up’ under it. It implies that the son holds a special place in her heart.
8.    ‘set no ceiling’
A ceiling is something that blocks you in, you cannot get past it. The mother set no limits on her son, he could be anything he wanted to be.
9.    ‘his bloody salary’
This implies that the mother believes that the result of the son’s ‘job’ will be death.
10. ‘the level of earth’
The mother has no power to change her son’s situation. Earth is used to emphasize her powerlessness on this level, the realm of ‘reality’.
11. ‘knee city’
This refers to the fact that the mother constantly prayed for her child.
12. ‘eye water covers you’
This implies that the mother cried constantly for the plight of her son. The fact that it ‘covers him’ speaks to the high quantity of tears that were shed.
13. ‘partner’
This is an informal saving scheme set up with a specific number of individuals for the duration of a specific time span. Each person agrees to pay a designated figure on a monthly basis. The ‘draws’ are decided, meaning who gets the money first, second, third etc, on a monthly basis.The banker then collects the money and gives the monthly pool to the person who is to receive their ‘draw’. Therefore, a ‘partnership’ is dependent upon the honesty of the banker, who could abscond with the money, as well as the honesty of the members of the savings scheme, who could decide NOT to pay after they have received their draw.
14. ‘banker’
The banker, or financial controller, of this partnership is the mother of a thief. This does not bode well for the mother if the thief on the cross learnt it from his mother.
15. ‘her draw though is first and last for she still throwing two hands as mother and father’.
This statement implies that though the mother has the advantage of first draw as mother, she loses that advantage because she also has the role of father. Mothers cannot father sons. The fact that the son has found a father figure proves this to be true. Therefore, she has the last draw, which carries with it the disadvantage of not receiving a full ‘draw’. The longer one waits for a draw is the more likely that dishonesty will come into play on the part of the participants.
MOOD/ ATMOSPHERE
The mood of the poem is reflective. The persona is thinking about a mother’s response to her son’s life choices.
TONE
The tone of the poem is pragmatic and pessimistic. The persona is telling the tale as it is, with no positive energy.
THEMATIC CATEGORY
Death, love/love and family relationship, survival, dreams and aspirations, childhood experiences, religion
Questions: 
Each student should post two questions please

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Comparative Literary Essay

Grade 11 1. Create a comparative draft for the essay question  QUESTION In the poems ‘An African Thunderstorm’ and ‘Sonnet composed upon Westminster Bridge’ the speakers is impressed with the majesty of nature. Write an essay in which you describe the scene witnessed in each poem and each speaker’s reaction to that scene. You must also comment on the effective use of one poetic device in each poem. 2. See the draft below, now complete the essay with needed substantiation and explanations. Poetry is an intentional expression in succinct form. Poets use words strategically like a weaving process. Robert Rubadiri born in Malawi uses his poem to evoke awareness to the effect of the west invasion on Africa and William Wordsworth in the 19 th century used his petrachan sonnet to reflect on his observation of a beautiful London morning. Both poets revolve around the theme of nature. An African thunderstorm  is a poem that deals with the theme man versus nature and it is

Dreaming Black Boy by James Berry

SUMMARY The poem is about a black boy who wishes that he could have regular things in life. Things such as a congratulatory hug, to be educated to the highest level and to travel without harassment. The persona yearns to stop fighting for the basic right to be successful and to rise above societal expectations. LITERARY DEVICES 1. REPETITION: The constant repetition of the phrase ‘I wish’ points to a yearning, a desperation even, for the basic things that life has to offer. The repetition gives credence to the idea that the persona might believe that his wishes are actually dreams that might not come true. 2. ALLUSION: Stanza 1, lines 6 and 7, alludes to slavery, the state of lacking control over one’s own life and destiny. The fact that reference is made to this hints to how the persona feels about his life. He does not feel as if he has control over it. Stanza 3, lines 19 to 20, alludes to Paul Robeson, a black intellectual, who attained success despite difficult circ

Grade 11 Language Paper 1

Grade 11 English Language April 20- April 24,       April 27- May 1 PAPER 1 TECHNIQUES Ø Scan through paper and read the instructions The paper is divided in two parts o    Grammar / Mechanics/ Vocabulary/ Spelling Section 1 skills Comprehension Grammar Punctuation Paragraphing o    Comprehension Section 2 Skills Comprehension inference Analysis Evaluation Ø Begin at the Comprehension section Read each comprehension 3 times o    First reading- 1.      Find the gist/ theme of the comprehension 2.      Underline all the new words o    Second reading 1.      Read through paragraph by paragraph and unravel meanings of literary devices 2.      Use context clues to find meanings of new words. 3.      Summarise paragraphs in a single sentence o    Third Reading 1.      Put all the summarised sentences together in a single par